Does God Exist? A Clear Analysis of the Debate and the Truth It Revealed
Does God Exist? A Clear Analysis of the Debate and the Truth It Revealed Introduction The debate between Mufti Shamail Nadwi and Javed Akhtar on the question “Does God exist?” must be understood in the correct order. First comes the debate itself and the logical outcome of that exchange. Then come the additional rational proofs that further strengthen the conclusion. Finally, the discussion must be placed in its proper framework: Islam, which is not philosophy, but truth. This blog follows that order deliberately. --- Part 1: The Debate — Where Mufti Shamail Nadwi Clearly Won In the debate, Mufti Shamail Nadwi stayed focused on the core question of existence. His argument was built on logic, necessity, and causality, not scripture or emotion. The Central Argument Mufti Sahab explained that: Everything that exists is either dependent or independent Dependent things cannot exist on their own The universe is dependent and contingent An infinite chain of dependence is impossible Therefore,...